Illiterate Society
When an individual is passionate about a subject, it is often difficult for them to accurately and fully express their points, lest they let their emotional investment get in the way of their message. Jonathan Kozol has a deep emotional trigger associated with the problem of illiteracy in America; this is expressed in his essay “The Human Cost of an Illiterate Society”. In it, Kozol manages to aptly express his feelings on the problem of illiteracy, through his use of personal anecdote, and the application of the problem to the average American. He does however lose a bit of control throughout the remainder of the essay, with his laundry list of examples of the disadvantages faced by illiterate individuals. Nonetheless, Kozol does pull the reader along with him emotionally, which is his ultimate goal.
Despite the essay’s main ammunition being its use of pathos, Kozol’s argument may be considered invalid without a logical appeal. Kozol brings the issue to the average, literate American by describing its effect on the democratic system in this country. The United States of America was founded on the basis of equal representation for all citizens, yet Kozol argues that the illiterate population of America is not significantly represented in the government, thus their needs are not being heard. The logical argument is often the most powerful argument, since no matter one’s background or opinion, facts and data are unchanging. Kozol places the solid fact that “60 million people are denied participation”, at the beginning of the essay in an attempt to make the reader understand the way that the problem will have repercussions on the reader themselves. Though the facts are not incredibly detailed or particularly ample, they are a necessary addition to this essay packed full of heartstring-pulling stories.All too often, calls to action seem to focus entirely on the audience, and none on the author. Kozol turns this around by divulging a personal detail from his life, with his dream about being lost in the Soviet Union. This is the beginning of the passage’s emotional appeal, giving the reader insight into the pleas and challenges faced by illiterates, from the perspective of someone who is the opposite. Kozol, a self-admitted person of privilege, has never known what it is like to be truly illiterate. After all, many foreign cater to the English-speaking visitor, or at the very least have a similarly-based language. The dream in which Kozol is stranded in the Soviet Union where not only the language is different, but the Cyrillic alphabet is completely undecipherable, shows how panic-inducing being illiterate is. It also illustrates the fact that the problems that come with illiteracy are not the fault of the individual themselves; if a Harvard graduate cannot handle the stress and tribulations of being illiterate, it is unlikely many other people can.
The remainder of the essay loses a bit of steam as far as maintaining the reader’s attention. Kozol goes on for five and a half pages describing the plight of illiterates through various anecdotes from illiterates themselves. While these stories are effective in drawing the sympathy and disbelief of the reader, for some, it may seem a bit of overkill. However, despite how it is perceived, the use of a multitude of incidents of the illiterate does represent how completely widespread the illiteracy epidemic is in America. The reader has to suffer along with the men and women and children in the narratives. Unlike the reader, who can discard the sheet of paper on which these stories are printed at anytime they please, the illiterates cannot escape their struggle of simply making it through the day without misstep or humiliation
I found this post very well-written and engaging, though I disagree that Kozol fails to hold the reader's attention. At least, I didn't personally didn't feel bored with or sick of the passage while reading it. I appreciated that you pointed out his deep emotional involvement, which I too felt come through quite strongly.
ReplyDeleteThis was very well-reasoned and well-written, and I agree with all of your points, except I believe that his use of the many examples helped to give us a view at the scope of the problem, and so it was a useful tactic. Really good analysis and commentary.
ReplyDeleteLara- Good observations on the passage. I too agree that much of the passage engages with pathos. I thought your observation that the reader suffers with the men and women through the long 5 and a half pages was interesting and apt. I like how you admitted that there were facts at the beginning because I had almost forgotten about them since as you will lost likely agree with: the passage is for the most part lacking in the facts department.
ReplyDelete-E
Your post was very precise and well-written. I liked your ended setnence, "illiterates cannot escape their struggle of simply making it through the day without misstep or humiliation ", because it emphasizes what the main point of the passage. Also, I think that his intensive use of examples is a bit too much.
ReplyDeleteLara I liked how you mentioned his experience in his dream being in the soviet union. Your analysis of his dream and his experience was very enlightening. I had some of the same ideas you did about his dream but didn't thing so in depth about the cyrillic alphabet. It would have been very scary to be in a place with an alphabet and language in front of you that you had no way to decipher. I really enjoyed reading your insight and agree that the essay does lose steam towards the end.
ReplyDeleteI noticed the use of pathos also! He really did attempt to appeal to the reader in that style. Calling it a "laundry list" is a good description, it is part of a book so it makes me wonder what else is in the book?
ReplyDelete