Tuesday, May 7, 2013

AP Essay Practice


2010 Form B Question 2

Much of the excerpt talks about the negatives of the “square states” and how they are flat, monotonous, and there is a stigma against the area. It tends to spawn bad things, like tornadoes, are prone to bad weather and crops, and are places other people pass over to get to more interesting places. There seems to be a complete lack of content in the Midwest, since the stories of the area are all fictitious. However, all these examples of how the Midwest is lacking are from the vantage point of people who do not live there. Also, every example of the dreariness is interspersed with many examples of how the media and people in high places almost revere the people of the Midwest. Politicians turn to Midwestern people, television heroins hail from the Midwest, because for some reason that makes them more wholesome than a similar woman born on the coast. Marquart also describes the area as the best place possible for her grandparents to land. The name Eureka implies positivity, and it is a new beginning for her grandparents. 

Paradox/Contradiction: Outsiders criticize the Midwest, yet put it up on a pedestal Quotes and opinions from many different people, some from the Midwest and some not

Example 1: This essay as very good, deserving of at least a solid 7, but I see why some people would give it an 8. The point that was made about the harsh landscape producing the classic all-American people was a very good point that I did not necessarily pick up on, but I feel like I explained in a different way in my writing. It acknowledged the author’s love and appreciation for the Midwest.

Example 2: This essay was not great, it missed the point that Marquart does have a deep love for the Midwest. it focused too much on the landscape, and not at all on its inhabitants, which was the main point of Marquart’s argument. It was not badly written, it just missed the main point, but it did analyze the landscape, so a 6 is an apt score, though i might have given it a 5. 

Example 3: Whoever wrote this essay was writing for the Literature test. They analyzed all the wrong things, like the language as opposed to the rhetoric. There was nothing that talked about the author’s love for the Midwest, which was the main point. It was very general, and did not go in depth enough. It is very deserving of its score of a 4.

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Post-Colonialism


Post-colonialist literary criticism examines the effects of colonialism on the native people, as well as the differences between Europeans and Africans, and the reasons for such clashes.


Kingsolver’s book The Poisonwood Bible has very clear commentary on the effects of colonialism in Africa. She points out the oppression, exploitation and cultural ignorance exhibited by the Europeans in Africa. Even though the book is set during a time when the Congo was still subject to colonialism, Kingsolver was writing from the perspective of a Post-Colonialist.

In the text, Kingsolver continually points out the condition of the African people. Often, it is through he unbiased eyes of Ruth May, who does not really comprehend the meaning of all that she sees. Most often, the faults of the white men in Europe are presented through the words and actions of Nathan Price. His behavior is often characterized as irrational and impervious to change, such as flattening out the garden beds, and his presumptuous claims of “saving” all of the Africans from their pagan ways are painted as irrational and impervious as well. He blatantly ignores the culture of the people, and tries to change their ways to fit his needs, despite the fact that he is in their home, imposing his will. This is reflective of most Europeans in Africa, who simply invade, use the people to fund themselves. Nathan uses them to feed his conscious and his ego, while the Belgians and other colonists use the Africans for economic gain through rubber and ivory. This situation is exemplified quite blatantly in the opinions of the Belgian doctor, “We Belgians made slaves of them and cut their hands off in the rubber plantations. Now you Americans have them for slave wage in the mines and let them cut off their own hands.” This quote perfectly describes the different approaches that the Westerners take, yet with the same outcome.

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Darkness vs. Apocalypse


Although Francis Ford Coppola’s Apocalypse Now is based off of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, there are striking differences. Other than the obvious changes in setting, the difference between the book and the movie that was most striking to me was the fact that Willard kills Kurtz at the end of the movie. In the book, Marlow simply brings Kurtz onto the boat where he dies of his illness.
One reason Coppola might have killed Kurtz was that it would really make no logical sense for Willard to leave Kurtz alive in this version of events. In the book, Kurtz really doesn’t harm Marlow, whereas in the movie, Marlon Brando captures Willard, and isn’t a very mice fellow in general. The gestures Marlow made toward Kurtz would not have fit in with the relationship that was established between Willard and Kurtz.
The cinematic effect of the simultaneous sacrificing of the water buffalo is another reason for murdering Kurtz violently. The natives are presumably sacrificing the buffalo for the greater good of their cause, just as Willard is killing Kurtz for the great good of the Vietnam War. It is the climax of the movie, the very end of the, quite frankly, extremely long film. From a dramatic standpoint, having Kurtz succumb to illness on the boat would make for a very boring end to the movie.
The version that I prefer is the death in the book. While the movie was much more engaging and intriguing, the slow, quite death of Kurtz in the book I feel is far more fitting. Kurtz lived life large. He did not stop and consider his actions, he simply acted. His influence in both versions is so great that he affects Marlow/Willard profoundly, even before actually meeting him. The dramatic death in the movie is fitting with how Kurtz lived his life: theatrical, public, bloody, even primitive. However, the quite, natural death in the book is far more revealing of the jungle, and the men who inhabit it. Africa kills many white men, but not in such a dramatic way as death by machete. Kurtz’ slow descent into death shows that Africa has no mercy on the invading Europeans. It eats them alive no matter what their standing was in the jungle. It was natural in a way for Kurtz to be eventually taken down by illness alone. It is a quite death for a man who lived so loudly.

Monday, March 18, 2013

HOD Difficulty

I was slightly confused about the importance of the book that Marlow finds in the ruined house. The title of the book was An Inquiry into some Points of Seamanship, by an author that Marlow cannot remember the exact name of. Marlow describes the book as incredibly dreary, and as a self-professed master of the sea, feels he is above the content of the book. Yet despite the "humble" nature of the book, he handles it with great care, and reads the entire thing. He claims the antiquity of the book is what intrigued him, but I get the feeling this is not entirely the case. What is the reason for focusing so intently on this worn out book? Also, I am not really sure what a cipher is in this context, and why it fascinates Marlow so much.

Monday, March 11, 2013

Juicy Quote

"But the darkness was here yesterday."

This quote intrigued me because of the cyclical nature of civilization. In history, we learn the "Laws of History", which explain the rise and fall of empires due to the same sorts of rules and mistakes. This sentence brings up the point that even the most advanced cities were once unexplored areas, and were perhaps even inhabited by "savages". Conrad is able to sympathize with the Congo through his narrator, since he sees that every great empire rose from the same "darkness" that is now seen in Africa.

Although Conrad may not have intended to pose this thought, this sentence also brings to mind the Romans who viewed the Thames as dark. Their empire was long gone during the narrative of the story, thus entertaining the idea that even Europe itself may give way to the power of Africa. Although this obviously has not happened, seeing as we view this book with modern knowledge, but it allows the characters in the book to consider a world were London and Europe were not the ultimate powers in world affairs.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

"Breaking Into the Thieves Kitchen"

A BRIEF SUMMARY:

“Breaking into the Thieves’ Kitchen” introduces the character of Sir Roger Casement, a prominent critic against the atrocities in the Congo. Very little is said in the book about his early life, but his parents died when he was quite young and was raised by his uncle. When he was nineteen, he went to the Congo with a shipping line, and helped supply the Sanford Exploration Expedition, as well as the surveyors of the railway along the river. He did not fit in every well among the white men of the Congo, for he was “too nice to the natives”. He saw firsthand the brutality occurring in the Congo, even by Stanley, who Casement considered to be somewhat of a hero. 


He first public protest was in a letter to the Aborigines Protection Society in 1894, and his way with words and compelling manner brought him to prominence. He even dined with King Leopold himself, and what was left of the royal family. He was a consul for the British government in Africa at the time, and Leopold was hoping to win him over to his side. Casement was not taken, for he had already seen enough of the Congo.

He made the acquaintance of Joseph Conrad, and even influenced Conrad’s opinion of Africa with his stories. However his dearest friend was actually E.D. Morel. The two were perfect for each other, for Morel provided the numbers and the organization, while Casement provided experience and hard evidence. They were almost like a crime-fighting duo, and even had cute little nicknames for each other. 

Casement was also a homosexual. Hochschild describes his personal life in great depth and detail, as well as the dangers it presented. Casement was surprisingly open and expressive in his journals about his sexual encounters. Despite seeing many other prominent gay men executed for their lifestyles, he continued to write in this “time bomb, with a fuse of an unknown length”. 

The chapter ends with an exceedingly ominous tone. Both Casement and Morel are taken into Pentonville prison in London, and one never comes out.  


Casement and Morel: BFFs



Discussion:

There is a lack of detail on Casement’s early life. What do you think Hochschild’s purpose was in leaving this out, especially considering the great detail he put into describing many of the other men’s childhoods?

Related: Casement was very kind to the natives, and was very unlike many of the other prominent men in the book. With all this talk about the motives of the awful people like Stanley and Leopold, what do you think motivated Casement? In short, we have an idea of what motivates evil, but what motivated good? Especially when Casement really has no common ground with the people he fought for.



Quiz Questions:

1. How did the timing of Casement’s actions and encounters with other significant characters in the book affect his work?
2. Why did the author go into so much detail about Casement’s sexuality?
3. What was so important about Casement’s anger?
4. Why did Morel and Casement make such a good pair?
5. What do you think caused Casement to channel his anger into a positive force, as opposed to the destruction that many other angry characters turned to?























Wednesday, February 27, 2013

The Psychology of Exploitation

“King Leopold’s Ghost” takes an interesting, and often overlooked, approach in its discussion of the exploitation of Africa. Adam Hochschild examines the psychology of the men who spearhead the atrocities committed in the Congo. This was done by drawing from their childhoods and projecting why and how they went about exploiting and abusing the people in Africa. King Leopold and his careful calcualtions, spawned from neglectful parents, Stanley, with his lust for attention and lack of sexual confidence, are two of the most prominent examples. The examination of these men explains why they did what they did, why they went to such lengths to achieve satisfaction.

I have considered ideas like this before, however not in great depth. This book has made me think about how important it is to understand the types of people that we put into power positions. Obviously due to good old fashioned monarchies, the people of the Congo and Belgium had no choice but to have Leopold in charge. However, Americans do have the ability to chose who governs us, so we should be aware of the deeper personality traits of those we select. Especially since a certain personality type tends to run for office, and this personality type has striking similarities to that of many serial killers. The type that would run for office is most similar to Stanley, who was drawn to an area where he could disregard other people and manipulate the media to boost his ego, just as many of our politicians do.

These sadistic men may have spearheaded the terrorization of Africa, however their plans would never have been carried out if it weren’t for an army of underlings. Leopold in particular relied solely on others to carry out the legwork, and never set foot on African soil. He may have used a great deal of manipulation in the execution of his plan, however, the tendency of humans to follow is also a notion that must be entertained if we are to understand genocides. It is hardwired into our brains to imitate others from the moment we are born. The story of Shin In Geun, the only known man to have escaped from a North Korean Prison camp is a perfect example of the curse of the follower. The people we are surrounded by give us out morals, and even justify our actions when these morals are compromised. This allows the countless white minions to mutilate and massacre the people of the Congo, for reward, a feeling of superiority, and the idea that it ay even the the “right” thing to do.