Tuesday, May 7, 2013

AP Essay Practice


2010 Form B Question 2

Much of the excerpt talks about the negatives of the “square states” and how they are flat, monotonous, and there is a stigma against the area. It tends to spawn bad things, like tornadoes, are prone to bad weather and crops, and are places other people pass over to get to more interesting places. There seems to be a complete lack of content in the Midwest, since the stories of the area are all fictitious. However, all these examples of how the Midwest is lacking are from the vantage point of people who do not live there. Also, every example of the dreariness is interspersed with many examples of how the media and people in high places almost revere the people of the Midwest. Politicians turn to Midwestern people, television heroins hail from the Midwest, because for some reason that makes them more wholesome than a similar woman born on the coast. Marquart also describes the area as the best place possible for her grandparents to land. The name Eureka implies positivity, and it is a new beginning for her grandparents. 

Paradox/Contradiction: Outsiders criticize the Midwest, yet put it up on a pedestal Quotes and opinions from many different people, some from the Midwest and some not

Example 1: This essay as very good, deserving of at least a solid 7, but I see why some people would give it an 8. The point that was made about the harsh landscape producing the classic all-American people was a very good point that I did not necessarily pick up on, but I feel like I explained in a different way in my writing. It acknowledged the author’s love and appreciation for the Midwest.

Example 2: This essay was not great, it missed the point that Marquart does have a deep love for the Midwest. it focused too much on the landscape, and not at all on its inhabitants, which was the main point of Marquart’s argument. It was not badly written, it just missed the main point, but it did analyze the landscape, so a 6 is an apt score, though i might have given it a 5. 

Example 3: Whoever wrote this essay was writing for the Literature test. They analyzed all the wrong things, like the language as opposed to the rhetoric. There was nothing that talked about the author’s love for the Midwest, which was the main point. It was very general, and did not go in depth enough. It is very deserving of its score of a 4.

No comments:

Post a Comment