Sunday, April 14, 2013

Darkness vs. Apocalypse


Although Francis Ford Coppola’s Apocalypse Now is based off of Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, there are striking differences. Other than the obvious changes in setting, the difference between the book and the movie that was most striking to me was the fact that Willard kills Kurtz at the end of the movie. In the book, Marlow simply brings Kurtz onto the boat where he dies of his illness.
One reason Coppola might have killed Kurtz was that it would really make no logical sense for Willard to leave Kurtz alive in this version of events. In the book, Kurtz really doesn’t harm Marlow, whereas in the movie, Marlon Brando captures Willard, and isn’t a very mice fellow in general. The gestures Marlow made toward Kurtz would not have fit in with the relationship that was established between Willard and Kurtz.
The cinematic effect of the simultaneous sacrificing of the water buffalo is another reason for murdering Kurtz violently. The natives are presumably sacrificing the buffalo for the greater good of their cause, just as Willard is killing Kurtz for the great good of the Vietnam War. It is the climax of the movie, the very end of the, quite frankly, extremely long film. From a dramatic standpoint, having Kurtz succumb to illness on the boat would make for a very boring end to the movie.
The version that I prefer is the death in the book. While the movie was much more engaging and intriguing, the slow, quite death of Kurtz in the book I feel is far more fitting. Kurtz lived life large. He did not stop and consider his actions, he simply acted. His influence in both versions is so great that he affects Marlow/Willard profoundly, even before actually meeting him. The dramatic death in the movie is fitting with how Kurtz lived his life: theatrical, public, bloody, even primitive. However, the quite, natural death in the book is far more revealing of the jungle, and the men who inhabit it. Africa kills many white men, but not in such a dramatic way as death by machete. Kurtz’ slow descent into death shows that Africa has no mercy on the invading Europeans. It eats them alive no matter what their standing was in the jungle. It was natural in a way for Kurtz to be eventually taken down by illness alone. It is a quite death for a man who lived so loudly.

No comments:

Post a Comment